English classes at any school and at any grade level always seem to cover the works of Shakespeare. William always seems to be the go-to guy when it comes to studying literature and theater. In fact, I took two courses on Shakespeare during my undergraduate career at UNCG. One course was titled the Early Plays and the other was titled the Later Works. The first course was instructed by the same professor that I had for a previous class: Geoffrey Chaucer.
The Chaucer class still remains as one of the most difficult and rewarding classes that I have taken. In much the same style as the Chaucer class, he was extremely intense when it came to studying the literature of William Shakespeare. We had daily oral quizzes, frequent class debates with a decided winner (no 'agree to disagree' situations), history lessons to accompany the history plays, and one of the most difficult finals I have ever taken. At the time, the stress of the class requirements definitely outweighed the positives of the class. However, I now appreciate the passion that was behind each lesson. He respected literature and writers more than any professor I've had while studying at UNCG. After allowing for a couple of semesters of breathing room, I decided to take the second of the Shakespeare sessions.
After some staff shuffling and class rearranging, I had a different instructor for the Later Plays class. I didn't think much about it and knew that this class would be interesting if it was anything like the first one. It was not. Our instructor explained to us the first day that plays are meant to be seen and not read silently. I'll admit, he does have a point. However, with that in mind, we would watch two or three different film versions of three plays. Every Monday Wednesday and Friday class time would be spent watching a video in the class with an either horribly outdated or horribly updated film version of one of Shakespeare's works. For assessment, we were required only to identify character quotes on a section test. This class was both the easiest and least rewarding course I have taken. These two polar opposite classes have led me to a moral conundrum. What kind of teacher will I be?
That's a tough one. On one hand, I would like to be the challenging teacher that pushes students to their limit and embraces difficulty. It may take years for students to understand why I pushed them so hard. They may not realize it now, but all of this is for their own good. On the other hand, students appreciate a teacher that understands how difficult it is to be in school. They would love a teacher that takes a more relaxed approach to the classroom. I wouldn't overwhelm them with folders of seemingly endless busywork or non-related pointless assignments. I understand that students have lives outside of the classroom and have work to do in other classes too. I don't need to pile assignments upon assignments on them do I?
There lies the dilemma. How do I balance assigning important work with work that they will want to do? I need to find coursework that is interesting, challenging, and rewarding. Easy, right? However, I can tell you that we will probably not watch the film version of Othello titled, "O". The earlier version with Laurence Fishburne was much better.
This is a great time to think about the kind of teacher you want to be. What is the end result for your students and how will you get them there? If "O" was the only way to hook in your students to Othello, would you use it? How can you be challenging and motivating at the same time. And that takes experience, because at first when you look out and see them all struggling, you wonder, what am I doing wrong? After a few years and students have come back to tell you how much the appreciate your class, you'll look out and say, I must be doing something right!
ReplyDelete