Top Ten List- English
- Contents include my Top Ten lists of Texts and Strategies for addressing Literacy in the Content Area -
Top Ten Text List (1 and 2):
1) Ellison, Ralph. “Battle Royal”. Invisible Man. Random House, Inc. 1952.
The short story “Battle Royal” is Chapter One in Ellison’s poignant novel addressing race relations in the South. The opening chapter is the narrative by a black man recalling a story when he was a young man still full of self-confidence and self-worth. He expresses his confusion in dealing with his race identity in the overheard advice and confession given by his grandfather on his deathbed. The grandfather confesses that he has been a traitor to his race and to keep up the fight and to “live with your head in the lion’s mouth”. His grandfather believes that blacks must “overcome 'em with yeses, undermine 'em with grins, agree 'em to death and destruction”.
With his grandfather’s confusing advice in the back of his mind, the narrator has been invited by the local white elite to make a speech that he had written for his high school graduation. The narrator considers himself an effective public speaker and has written a speech that explains that humility is the key to success. He is looking forward to giving his speech to these prestigious men and is annoyed when he is “asked” to participate in a boxing match with the other black boys that are in attendance. The boys are “encouraged” to participate in a blindfolded boxing match in which the narrator hopes will end quickly with he as the victor so that he will still be able to deliver his speech. He makes it to the final two but loses and joins the other boys as they scramble to gather coins that have been tossed onto an electrified rug. The narrator remains optimistic when he is allowed to give his speech to the white audience even as the drunken crowd laughs at his mention of equality. Although he is swallowing blood from the brutal battle royal, the narrator is more concerned with his own ability than the horrors that he was just made a victim. After the speech, he is given a briefcase and an academic scholarship to a black college. The story concludes with a dream he has in which he attends the circus with his grandfather who refuses to laugh at the clowns and a letter from him that states, “To Whom It May Concern: Keep This Nigger-Boy Running.”
The “Battle Royal” chapter is full of writing techniques such as imagery and symbolism. As a class, we would examine the technical aspects of this story and how they relate to Southern race relations in the early twentieth century. I would divide the class into pairs or in threes and ask them to examine and identify all of the examples of symbolism they can find within the story. We could then reconvene as a class and openly discuss our findings. Not only would this text be a great example to explain literary devices, it is a great piece of literary history. This piece, and the larger work it is within, is an excellent source of fictional information outlining the struggles of minorities throughout the early stages of the Civil Rights movement.
2) www.theonion.com. Onion, Inc. n.d. 2010.
The Onion is a satirical online and print newspaper that takes both fictional and actual events and parodies them in the style of an editorial piece. The Onion features satire on a wide range of topics in a similar style as a print newspaper including interviews, opinion pieces, local and international news, sports, historical events, and fictional reader-submitted commentary. “America’s Finest News Source” also includes standard newspaper items such as horoscopes, editorial cartoons, statistics, and infographics
Although the website rarely includes content that is inappropriate for the high school student, it sometimes contains language that may be deemed vulgar or otherwise unsuitable for individuals under the age of 18. With that in mind, I will choose an expansive selection of articles from this website that are age appropriate for the high school 11th grader. I will use these articles to explain the characteristics of satire and the many forms it may take.
The Onion’s written pieces can be an excellent example of written humor and satire. The pieces are all obviously fictitious but often take a tongue-in-cheek approach to common events and people. We will use The Onion as a guide and create our own classroom satirical newspaper. Each student can take a topic or style and write his or her own article or piece using satire and humor. The range of topics could include political satire, local news, celebrity profiles, sports, or historical events or anything of the students’ choosing. The students will be given the option of writing a piece, creating a cartoon, or making a visual component such as a “stat shot” or “infographic”. The students will compose a rough draft during class and, after my review, complete the final version for homework.
Top Ten Strategies List (1 through 3):
1) Journal Entries (Assessment)- I would like to incorporate the use of journals in the classroom to evaluate and assess the students’ comprehension of the curriculum materials. I would vary the times in which these assignments are given so that the students are unaware when they might be assigned and to avoid the dread that would come with daily quizzes. These journals would require a critical analysis of the readings and would move beyond recalling character and quote identifications. I would prompt the students by allowing them to choose one of three questions to answer. Each question would be based more on understanding the overview and “point” of the readings and would be graded on a pass/ fail type grading scale. These journal entries would allow the student to reflect on the readings and provide personal insight into what they’ve read.
2) “The W’s”: Who, What, When, Where, Why (Struggling Readers)(Reading Comprehension)- This straightforward comprehension technique would help students break down an otherwise difficult reading assignment. The students would use the W’s to get at the basics of the reading and help outline the piece for them. Breaking down a difficult piece into these basic components could help the struggling reader with overall comprehension. Identifying the W’s on paper could facilitate unconscious reading strategies to deal with confusing texts.
This technique would work well in pairs in which the students were allowed to discuss the texts with their partner and create an outline of the work. After a reading homework assignment, I would purposely pair a struggling reader with an active reader to encourage peer-to-peer teaching and instruction. Working together and verbally discussing the W’s, the students could also gain a greater understanding of writing elements such as theme, motivation, plot, antagonist, protagonist, etc.
3) Reading Aloud (Struggling Readers): Reading short texts aloud in class could assist struggling readers in both the reading and listening aspects. This technique could work best with examining brief written works such as short stories or poetry. We could divide the class into several small groups to accommodate students who may feel uncomfortable reading in front of the class. This technique would allow for informal assessment as a visit each group to review reading abilities. Struggling readers and students with comprehension difficulties would have the opportunity to listen to the readings in addition to individual silent reading along.
The Onion is a great text to use in classes. It reminds students that we can be playful with language! I also like that you chose the first part of Invisible Man rather than the entire book. Although I love the whole thing, it doesn't hurt to pick and choose some excerpts for students. We can't read everything and that might just hook in some students to read it on their own. When using the read aloud strategy, make sure that you are sensitive to English Language Learners who may not be confident yet in their reading. This might be something to do one-on-on or, like you said, in small groups with other similar readers.
ReplyDelete