Wednesday, July 21, 2010

Top Ten List- Group Three

Top Ten List- English
- Contents include my Top Ten lists of Texts and Strategies for addressing Literacy in the Content Area -
Top Ten Text List (6 and 7):

6) Finding Forrester. Writ. Mike Rich. Dir. Gus Van Sant. Perf. Sean Connery, Rob Brown. Columbia Pictures. 2000.

Jamal Wallace is an inner city black youth who has hidden his scholastic talents by completing only what is necessary and purposely achieving average grades. The store begins by showing inner city life and Jamal playing basketball with his friends. Jamal accepts the dare from his friends to break into the home of the neighborhood recluse and return with an item taken from inside as proof. Inside, Jamal is distracted by the vast collection of books and is leaves his book bag behind when he is surprised by the owner. The recluse hangs Jamal’s bag from his window as a taunt to come back and retrieve his belongings. Jamal returns to the home and discovers that his own collection and writings have been edited and corrected by the man who owned the home.


After an exceptional standardized test performance, Jamal and his mother are invited to meet with the school’s guidance counselor to discuss Jamal’s academic future. He reluctantly agrees to attend a mostly-white prep school that will take advantage of his academic gift as well as his basketball skills. At the new school, Jamal frequently clashes with an English teacher who resents Jamal’s arrogance and willingness to challenge him in class. In this class, the class is assigned to read the only book published by the author William Forrester. This book has been deemed a masterpiece by many and especially by the English teacher who seems to go out of his way to explain Forrester’s motivation behind the book and why he has not written another. Jamal recognizes Forrester from the book jacket and discovers that he is the hermit who had corrected his work and has lived a life of solitude for many years in the corner apartment.

Jamal asks Forrester to help him with his writing and, in return, agrees to never reveal his identity or whereabouts. Jamal and Forrester develop an unlikely friendship as Jamal spends nearly every afternoon working with the famous author. As Forrester is helping Jamal hone his craft, Jamal is helping Forrester overcome his agoraphobia and interpersonal disability. In their ongoing writing exercise, Forrester allows Jamal to use a single sentence as a jumping off point in the piece he is composing while at the author’s apartment. Jamal disobeys the agreement to never let the writing leave the apartment when he is forced to complete a writing assignment assigned by the obnoxious English teacher. The teacher recognizes the opening sentence as appearing in an essay written by William Forrester and accuses Jamal of plagiarism. Unless he can prove that he had permission from the author, Jamal will be expelled from the school and lose his scholarship. However, he agrees to the pact and is prepared to face expulsion by not revealing that he knows Forrester.

The end of the school year is highlighted by a literature contest amongst the students of the school. Forrester makes a surprise appearance during the event and reads a short piece without revealing the author. The school and the English teacher are very impressed and ask to what they owe the pleasure of his appearance. Forrester reveals that the author is Jamal to the shock and surprise of the school. Through the film, Jamal has learned that his knowledge and writing skills are valuable and that he should apply himself in order to succeed. In short, Forrester has found friendship again and what it means to be alive.

I would like to show this film to my class simply because it is an uplifting story. It covers a range of relatable topics including diversity, academic success and acceptance, unlikely friendships, and writing. The story explains that there is nothing to be ashamed of in regards to doing well in school. Although Jamal was a gifted student, he was initially reluctant to reveal his educational fortitude to his friends and family for fear of rejection or mockery. The movie also touches on issues of race and diversity. Because Jamal is a black inner city youth, he is often the recipient of stereotypical viewpoints from both educators and his peers. The stereotype that one cannot be good at sports and good at academics is also displayed.

7) Dylan, Bob and Jacques Levy. “Hurricane”. Desire. Columbia Records. 1975.

This protest song was written about the former middleweight boxer Rubin “Hurricane” Carter who, along with John Artis, was convicted of triple homicide stemming from what many believe to be racially motivated. Carter and Artis were sentenced to four life sentences and continued to maintain their innocence throughout the trial and Carter’s eventual meeting with Bob Dylan. The trial and beginning years of serving were met with controversial claims of unreliable eyewitness testimony, racial profiling, and investigation inaccuracy. After serving nearly twenty years of his sentence, Carter sent Bob Dylan a copy of his autobiography detailing his false conviction and sentence. Bob Dylan and Jacques Levy are inspired to write a “cinematic” song that details the incident and makes accusations of wrongful prosecution. The song was re-recorded with several adjusted lyrics after being threatened by a lawsuit involving the eyewitnesses.

The song’s popularity and several benefit concerts for Carter may have contributed to the case being re-opened and establishing a new trial. Awaiting the new trial, Carter allegedly assaulted a supporter and fundraiser, which led celebrity spokesmen on his behalf stepping away from his support. Despite the new trial, Carter and Artis were again convicted of murder and sentenced to two consecutive life sentences each. However, the case was addressed once again in 1985 and it was ruled that Carter had not received a fair trial and the charges were dropped.

This song is extremely interesting in that it brings up the subject of fact vs. fiction in writing. The song’s main controversy stems from the creative liberty the writers took in detailing the “facts” of the event. Dylan and Levy use a “cinematic” writing style for “Hurricane” that uses specific details regarding the event and eyewitness quotes and testimony. The song also explains investigation issues of racial profiling and police officer indiscretions. However, the writers utilized poetic license in many of the details for dramatic effect, which blurred the line between fact and fiction. Many believe that the song’s details were created out of imagination rather than the “real” incident.

The song and associated controversy should allow for great class discussion on matters of fact vs. fiction, writer motivation, and moral responsibility. I would like to use this song and class discussion to set up a reflection paper on these issues and allow the students to think critically on these ideas: fiction vs. non-fiction, artist responsibility, and perspective as truth.


Top Ten Strategies List (6 through 8):

6) Anticipation Guide (Reading Comprehension) (Critical Reading)- Anticipation guides seem like an excellent pre-reading strategy to employ for struggling readers or to help guide students through a difficult reading. These guides can help establish particular themes or issues that will be explored during the reading and to activate the students’ prior knowledge on the subject before the text is explored. The students will be asked to think critically on the pre-established ideas that will allow for a base to which the readings can be understood. These guides can also be used during and after readings as well. Students can use these guides as a reference during the readings or as a reflection after. An interesting exercise would be to have the students write a short reflection based on the guide before the reading and then after to see how and if ideas or knowledge has changed. Post reading, these guides can also be good sources for class discussion and topics for group analysis.

7) Writing Break (Struggling Readers)- This method can be employed at any time during a lesson or class activity. It allows the students a chance to quietly define what they have learned or realize what they are having difficulty with. I could use these as informal assessments to gain an idea on how the students are grasping a particular subject or topic. These short assignments seem to help with classroom attention in that they are required to stop and write a reflection on what they are learning. These are relatively quick and easy activities that require little commitment from teacher or student. I could prompt writing breaks with broad questions to allow further topic exploration by the student.

8) Silent Discussion (Reading Comprehension) (Diverse Learners)- I would group the students in threes or fours and ask them to discuss a pre-assigned question or topic from a previous reading. The students would have to answer the question on a piece of paper and then pass the paper to another group member for analysis and response. All group members would be writing at the same time and then pass along their “note” to the person next to them once the allotted time (five minutes or so) has expired.

This activity benefits students who may feel awkward or shy in discussing topics aloud in class. English Language Learners can benefit as well in that they can “discuss” pre-assigned topics with their classmates without the added difficulties of language speaking. These discussions would allow for added time for thought and give students more time to get their point across. The activity aids in reading comprehension because it requires the student to think and write critically about the assigned topic or question.

1 comment:

  1. Great detail in your postings! The song is a great idea and I think that students would get a lot out of an assignment like that. I love the movie Finding Forrester. I wonder how you might integrate it into a unit, maybe we books like Walter Dean Meyer's Monster... There are several clips that touch on issues of racism that you could use to interest students. I love to use anticipation guides! To make them more hands-on you can hand up signs in your room that say agree, disagree, maybe, don't care and have students get up and move to the corners of the room that coincide with their opinion. Then you ask the to explain.

    ReplyDelete