Top Ten List- English
- Contents include my Top Ten lists of Texts and Strategies for addressing Literacy in the Content Area -
Top Ten Text List (3 through 5):
3) Irving, Washington. “Rip Van Winkle”. The Sketchbook of Geoffrey Crayon, Gent. New York: C.S.Van Winkle, 1819.
The well-known short story "Rip Van Winkle" was written by Washington Irving and describes the misadventure of the title character. The story takes place in two different time periods: before and after the American Revolution. Rip Van Winkle lives in a village at the foothills of the Catskill Mountains in New York State.
He is well liked by everyone in the town excluding his wife who is frustrated with his laziness and inability to work for profit, which has led to the neglect of his home and farm. To escape the constant nagging of his wife, Rip escapes to the solitude of the mountains with only his rifle and trusty dog. There in the forest, he encounters a man carrying a jug of liquor and strange men playing a game called “ninepins” who all persuade him to drink with them. After drinking with these odd men, Rip decides to lie down and nap. Rip awakens to find that his dog is gone and his rifle has rusted. Rip returns to town to discover that twenty years have passed and that his wife and most of his friends have died. Rip finds his daughter and goes to live with her and her husband. Rip quickly returned to his old habits and sets about telling his tale.
I have chosen this short story because it is well known and often considered a staple in American literature. Aside from the technical merits, the story itself is entertaining and fairly easy to read and follow. Technically, it is packed with rich symbolism regarding the American Revolution and contains many potential themes for discussion or interpretation. A good class activity would be to explore the various themes within the work. I would divide the class into pairs or threes and assign questions that involve a particular theme: What are some of the physical changes that have occurred since Rip fell asleep? Has Rip been punished for his laziness or disregard for profitable work? How is Rip’s life different now than it was before he fell asleep? How are themes of the American Revolution dispersed throughout this story? We would choose one group to read the question aloud and then explain to the class what their answers were. The other students would be allowed to respond, agree, or disagree with the presenter. This activity should allow for open discussion of the work as well as demonstrate the varying ways that individuals can interpret a text. It would also serve to define literary concepts such as setting, symbolism, and theme.
4) Roethke, Theodore. “Root Cellar”. The Lost Son and Other Poems. Garden City, New York: Doubleday, 1948.
“Root Cellar” is a poem by American poet Theodore Roethke that vividly describes the contents of a root cellar. As with many works of poetry, summarizing this poem is difficult. It is a relatively short poem of 11 lines and uses concrete images and vivid detail to describe a root cellar which is a partially above ground or underground structure to store fruits, plants, vegetables, or other perishable items for later use.
“Root Cellar” is a great creative writing lesson in imagery and tone. I would like to use his use of words to demonstrate how to develop tone within a poem. I would ask the students what makes this poem “effective” or “believable”. Do we believe that the narrator is describing an actual root cellar? Why? How do we know how the narrator feels about the root cellar? We would then have a “5 Senses” writing exercise in which we independently write a poem describing a particular location such as a classroom, dentist office, backyard, etc. The student would need to address each of the five senses in their poem and use these descriptions to establish a particular tone for the poem. I would first read two examples that I have written and then allow the students class time to write their own. I would then allow the students to read their poem aloud in class.
5) Cisneros, Sandra. The House on Mango Street. Houston, Texas: Arte Público Press, 1984.
The House on Mango Street is novella that is constructed using a series of fictional first-person vignettes written by a young girl named Esperanza Cordero. Through Esperanza’s voice, Cisneros details the life of a young Latina girl growing up in an urban Chicago ghetto who has found writing as a way to express her feelings and as a method to escape the difficulties of life in a poor neighborhood. This coming-of-age book outlines Esperanza’s life over the course of one year and describes the many characters that come and go through her neighborhood. These series of vignettes also outlines Esperanza’s difficulty in trying to understand her personal physical and emotional changes and how she is developing her own sense of self and identity. Esperanza hopes to one day leave this neighborhood but she understands that it will always be a part of who she is.
The book is quite brutal in its honest portrayal of ghetto life. Alone, the book could be a great read for high school students as it provides an unflinching portrait of Latino life in urban Chicago in which the streets are dangerous and extended families live in one or two bedroom apartments. The book also challenges the idea of “home” and how it relates to self and identity. I think this paper would be a great way to introduce an independently written short response paper. I would like to give several choices of prompts that the students could use as a jumping off point to write this short paper. Some examples could be: How has Esperanza’s idea of self changed throughout the book? How would Esperanza define “home”? How are male and female roles in society defined through this book?
Top Ten Strategies List (4 and 5):
4) Admit Slips (Reading Comprehension)- Admit slips are an excellent way for students to reflect on their assigned homework reading in a thoughtful and non-graded way. The topics to write about could guide the students through the reading and provide some framework in understanding the reading in a critical way. The questions could be thought provoking or could simply provide summary assistance to the reader as they are reading.
I would like to present the students with these topics at the end of the class prior to the homework reading and then make them necessary to enter the class on the following day. These admit slips could then be reviewed by me and then used as framework for class discussion. I could ask the students to read their admit slips aloud for the class and then use that to facilitate class discussion or small group discussion of the homework reading.
5) Exit Slips (Engaging Diverse Cultures)- Exit slips are a form of informal assessment that would give the students an opportunity to express how things are going in the class. I would use these to assess what the student is having difficulty with as well as to assess what is going right. This method can assist students who may feel uncomfortable speaking in class or approaching the teacher with issues they may be having. Diverse learners may feel that their problems with the material may be too unimportant to bring up in class so exit slips are a way for them to let me know how things are going.
These slips could be an excellent method for me to shape my teaching strategies around the students’ feedback. Acting almost as a suggestion box, students would be able to play an active role in my lesson plans and provide me with real-time feedback on material being covered. A unit test is too late to discover that your students had difficulty with a particular subject. Exit slips would provide me with knowledge on how to shape the next day’s lesson or if more time needs to be spent on a particular subject. I could use these to help identify and engage diverse learners in the class before it is discovered after a formal assessment.
Great description! I can tell that you are thinking about ways to implement some strategies next year. For next time, think of some texts that are movies, newspaper articles, songs that you can connect with some of the great texts that you mentioned here. Are there any similar kinds of stories to Rip? Could they write their own tale?
ReplyDeleteNathan!
ReplyDeleteYou sound like such an English teacher. Makes me smile. : o) I really like exit slips in particular because it helps you figure out what they actually took away from the lesson and what they still need help understanding.