Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Top Ten List- Group Four

Top Ten List- English

- Contents include my Top Ten lists of Texts and Strategies for addressing Literacy in the Content Area -

Top Ten List- English


Top Ten Text List (8 through 10):


8) Chopin, Kate. “Desiree’s Baby”. The Complete Works of Kate Chopin. Ed. Per Seyersted. Baton Rouge Louisiana State UP. 1969.


“Desiree’s Baby” is the short story by female American writer Kate Chopin. The story is set before the Civil War in Louisiana and deals with race relations in America. Desiree is the adopted daughter of wealthy white Creoles named Monsieur and Madame Valmondé who found her abandoned in the shadows of the pillars of the estate’s gateway. She is well loved but especially by her mother because she is her only daughter. A wealthy local named Armand, who she has always known, sees Desiree by the pillar where she was found as a toddler and falls instantly in love with her and must marry her. Despite the warnings of her adopted father regarding Desiree’s questionable lineage, Armand marries her and they have a child together. After the child’s birth, Desiree explains the positive change in Armand’s demeanor who has been more kind, even to his slaves.


However, Desiree begins to notice that Armand has become distant and that many individuals are taking notice of the baby’s physical characteristics. Armand has also returned to punishing his slaves but with a renewed harshness. It wasn’t until a young quadroon (1/4 African) was helping with the baby that Desiree realized what many others have noticed. Her son has the same complexion as the ¼ African boy. When Armand returns, she asks him what it means and he explains that it must mean that she is not 100% white. She writes a letter to her mother who says that it would be best for Desiree to return to her family’s home. Her husband is resolute in his decision that she leave with the child immediately. She leaves hastily without taking any belongings and runs away never to return.


Once she leaves, Armand commands his slaves to burn all of his wife and son’s possessions. Included in these belongings are letters that were written by his mother to his father declaring her absolute love for him. She thanks Armand’s father for his devotion to her and explains that she is happy that Armand will never find out the truth that she belongs to the slave race. It is at this moment that Armand realizes that he is the one who passed on the African heritage to his son.


The short story hits on themes covering love and devotion, women in society, and race relations in America. The story also explains the nature of race relations and racism in America before the Civil War. The story explains the difficulty of mixed race relations in the South and prejudices associated with mixed race children. Armand considered his wife to be a traitor to her race although she had no control over her upbringing or the actions of her parents. Despite the interesting storyline and dramatic plot twist regarding Armand’s mother, the writing is packed with important literary devices. Elements of setting, symbolism, and foreshadowing are very prevalent throughout this work.


9) www.slate.com. The Washington Post Company. Newsweek Interactive Company LLC. 2007.


The following site description is taken directly from Slate’s “about us” page. “Slate is a daily magazine on the Web. Founded in 1996, we are a general-interest publication offering analysis and commentary about politics, news, business, technology, and culture. Slate's strong editorial voice and witty take on current events have been recognized with numerous awards, including the National Magazine Award for General Excellence Online. The site, which is owned by The Washington Post Company, does not charge for access and is supported by advertising revenues.”

The website contains daily commentary on subjects such as politics, technology, art, business, and science. Most pieces are written from a strong editorial point-of-view with a multitude of opinions represented across the topic spectrum. Most of the commentary reflects varied opinions on hot debate topics of current events. The website remains independent in that it encourages open discussion and comments on the pieces it electronically publishes. I enjoy daily reading of the website because it covers a wide range of topics that are not covered in other websites, online publications, or traditional newspapers. The website’s published content is informative and engaging but the real entertainment comes in the form of the “comments” section. The best and worst discussions of the subject matter are discussed in the open reader comments section at the bottom of every article.


This section covers a host of response techniques including anger, sarcasm, constructive criticism, agreement, and complete disregard for the topics discussed. I would like to use the website content as well as the comments section to have a classroom discourse on the topics of persuasion and criticism. We would read the pieces and discuss the creative writing elements of persuasive writing including what makes a work credible and believable. We would analyze the work to discuss what makes an opinion piece effective and how the writer uses these elements to relay their own opinion in a positive way. The comments section would also set up a great discussion on positive reinforcement and how to “agree to disagree”. We would use this section to analyze effective counter-responses and how to express a differing opinion without relying on negative elements such as condescension and sarcasm.


10) Hemingway, Ernest. “Hills Like White Elephants”. Men Without Women. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. 1927.


“Hills Like White Elephants” is the short story by the American writer Ernest Hemingway of two individuals who are known as “Jig” and “the American”. It is difficult to summarize this story because most of the meaning is hidden in the text. The text outlines a man versus woman struggle but the language Hemingway uses does more to establish mood and setting than it does to define plot points. The story is unique in that it uses a third person narrative with quotes from the two characters. With that in mind, it calls on the reader to establish the feeling and thought processes of the characters.


The story begins with these two characters waiting in an Ebro River Valley, Spain station for a train bound for Madrid. It is clear that Jig is younger than her male companion because she has become bored with their travels and states that everything new they drink tastes like licorice. Her obvious boredom and complaints irritates the man. Their gentle bickering soon turns to a much more serious disagreement over an operation that he wishes the woman to undergo. The actual subject of their disagreement is never explicitly stated. However, through various contextual clues, it is believed to be a disagreement over an impending abortion. It is clear that the American wishes her to undergo the procedure so that they may resume their life of travel and leisure. It is apparent that she wishes to keep their child and settle down but sarcastically agrees to continue with the operation. The story ends with the American taking their bags to the other side of the station and returning to ask her how she feels. She replies, “There is nothing wrong with me. I feel fine”.


“Hills Like White Elephants” covers a range of topics including the difficult subject of abortion and the debate involving who has the right to choose, the man or woman. The story includes an open-ended lesson of responsibility and relationships. Hemingway utilizes a host of literary techniques in this short story as well. Literary elements like setting, mood, and symbolism are well established in this work. Hemingway’s unique third person style lends to multiple interpretations of the character’s intentions and inner thought processes. The conversation is only heard as it would be through actual verbal dialogue. There are no setups or inner dialogue to explain or compliment the conversation. The story could make for great classroom discussion in that it covers the difficult subject of abortion and the ambiguity of the character’s intentions could lead to debate. The difficulty in covering this short story would be to keep the focus on the story itself and not the ethical and moral arguments of abortion. We would have to maintain the perspective of the characters and not bring in a personal debate of the often-heated subject of abortion.


Top Ten Strategies List (9 and 10):


9) Character Debate (Critical Reading) (Assessment)- A Character Debate utilizes a student’s understanding of a particular individual’s character traits and how that character would behave in a unique situation. Each student would be assigned a character that would be covered in a future reading assignment. The students would be assigned to follow this character through a short story or novel and would be required to debate other classmates through the perspective of that particular character. The students would be required to accurately read the material and then translate what they have learned about their assigned character. The class would choose a hypothetical debate topic and the student would be required to explain how that character would behave in that particular situation. The students could be asked to appear dressed as their assigned character and speak as their characters would. The class would then reflect in a short writing on how well they believe the student defended their assigned character by using evidence from the text. This activity would require a critical reading of the text because the students would be required to use the character’s perspective in a scenario unrelated to the original story. I would also be able to use this as an assessment in that I could determine how well the student understood the material through the presentations as well as through the other students’ short reflections.

10) Teacher-Student Silent Correspondence (Engaging Diverse Cultures)- I would use this technique to find how the students are doing overall throughout the semester. Throughout several points of the semester, I would prompt the students to reflect on how their school year is going and ask them if there are any outstanding issues or concerns. This would allow students the opportunity to express to me how the semester is going in an informal way that may be better suited to otherwise withdrawn or quiet students. It seems obvious that my teaching strategies would reflect and adapt to how my students are feeling and this would give me the feedback that I need to make any needed changes in curriculum or pace of the class. Regular assessment would relate to me how well the students comprehend the material and this correspondence would let me know how they are relating to the material.

1 comment:

  1. I love the Hemingway story! I used to use this in my 10th grade classroom to illustrate the power of dialogue. I had them go out to a public space and transcribe a conversation. Then they came back and turned it into a story. Wow! The things they wrote were really interesting and we learned how to use dialogue to tell a story. Yes, the issue of abortion is alive in the story, but it leaves open the question... is this the thing to do. That is what is so powerful about it! It really captures the complexities of such an issue in very subtle way. I agree that Slate will catch their attention!

    ReplyDelete